ค้นหาจากครู ภาษาอังกฤษ หลากหลายคน...
China flagRoy
Do rich people create jobs? In America, the main argument for cutting taxes for rich people is that rich people are "job creators." But this argument has a fatal flaw. As we know, an economy has two components, supply and demand. The interaction between them underlies the economic mechanism. If you cut taxes for the rich, and hopefully they spent the saved money on investment, there would be more job openings. However, if the other people, not the affluent ones, did not have extra money to buy the newly-produced products/services, the new businesses would fail and the new jobs would disappear. Accordingly, we should say it loud and clear: rich people alone do not create jobs. Demand creates jobs. One can create demand, though, through R&D. Therefore, a right way of promoting economic growth is not to cut taxes for the rich, but to invest in science, education, and infrastructure, helping enhance creativity and productivity.

การแก้ไข · 7

0
Also, James, there are vast regional differences when we try to define rich or poor. For example, if a guy living in New York City makes 20K a pear, he can hardly consider himself rich, I guess. However, at a smaller city, like Buffalo, NY, he can live like a king. I am not familiar with the tax code about levying tax on incomes from other countries. I guess deductions could be available in this case. Otherwise, double taxation may occur, which is a very bad arrangement. It is true that small businesses cannot compete with, say, Walmart, in terms of economy of scale. Antitrust laws are useful in containing the market power of large corporations, but their effectiveness should not be overestimated. Small businesses could stand out in niche markets, though.
0
James, thank you very much for your comments, which are pretty insightful and informative. I totally agree that there is no universal criterion of being rich or wealthy, which embodied in the arguments when Obama proposed to increase the marginal income tax rate for the rich last time. He thought that a family was rich if their annual income reached 25K. By contrast, Republican's criterion was 1 million. And they finally compromised at 40K, if my memory is reliable.
0
Also, Peg, the taxation system in the US is very convoluted, replete with loopholes. Although the nominal corporate tax rate is high, the real rates for quite a few large corporations are pretty low. Some do not even pay a penny. Also, as you mentioned, they can take advantage of tools for international tax avoidance, which are unavailable for small businesses. For this reason, presidential aspirants are competing with each other, in proposing better tax polices.
0
Thank you, Peg, so much for your comments and for your compliment. I truly appreciate it. In my view, rich people do not necessarily need to be business owners themselves. They can, for instance, buy stocks from other businesses, which make investments, using the money collected by selling stocks.
0
My response isn't exactly what you asked, but it's related to the topic. "Rich" or wealthy are very relative. Even people in the US who make an an income of $200,000 per year are still only making a tiny fraction of the amount of money of what the truly wealthy make. So when talking about the rich or wealthy, it can be very misleading to just categorize all of the people who make over 100k per year into one group. It is also worth noting that the US is one of the only countries in the world that taxes their citizens regardless of which country that they are living in. It is also true that large companies have more influence and power in relation to US laws, and that they also have advantages in terms of lower costs if their business deals in high volume. For example, it would be nearly impossible for a small business in the US to buy socks from China and sell them in the US and be able to compete with a company such as Walmart, because the larger company is dealing in such high volume. They pay lower prices for their products, they are able to store them more cheaply, and they are able to accept a smaller profit margin.

ต้องการความก้าวหน้าที่เร็วขึ้นหรือไม่

เข้าร่วมชุมชนแห่งการเรียนรู้และทดลองใช้แบบฝึกหัดฟรี!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today