ค้นหาจากครู ภาษาอังกฤษ หลากหลายคน...
Egypt flagAhmed
How SOME Tutors Damage Students' Fluency When I speak, please, let me speak. Because I speak to be fluent. And I will NEVER be fluent if you keep interrupting me every now and then to correct my mistakes. We shouldn't confuse Fluency with Perfection. Fluency means to be able to express yourself freely and smoothly regardless of any mistakes you make. My point is, as long as I am understandable and I can get my message across to you, then no need to interrupt me. Mistakes can be discussed later on at the end of the conversation. We can dedicate the last 10 minutes for that matter. The continuous correction of mistakes has nothing to do with fluency improvement. However, it leaves the student hesitant and worried about his speech. Instead of thinking about what to say and expressing it freely and automatically, he keeps thinking about his pronunciation and putting the verbs in the correct tenses. Interruption damages students' confidence and kills fluency.

การแก้ไข · 4

1

How SOME Tutors Damage Students' Fluency

When I speak, please, let me speak. Because I speak to be fluent. And I will NEVER be fluent if you keep interrupting me every now and then to correct my mistakes. We shouldn't confuse Fluency with Perfection. Fluency means to be able to express yourself freely and smoothly regardless of any mistakes you make. My point is, as long as I am understandable and I can get my message across to you, then no need to interrupt me. Mistakes can be discussed later on at the end of the conversation. We can dedicate the last 10 minutes for that matter. The continuous correction of mistakes has nothing to do with fluency improvement. However, it leaves the student hesitant and worried about his speech. Instead of thinking about what to say and expressing it freely and automatically, he keeps thinking about his pronunciation and putting the verbs in the correct tenses. Interruption damages students' confidence and kills fluency.


Ahmed, thank you for sharing your authentic experience from a learner's point of view. For example, when someone is trying to learn grammar, his grasp of the concept takes precedence over his fluency in speaking. When he is practising speaking, he should still be allowed to do so in an uninterrupted fashion till he is done before constructive feedback is given. The reason is very simple: Allow the student to commit the mistake so that he will remember that mistake deeply and repeat it less often in future. Lastly, as tutors and teachers on Italki, we must be mindful of the fact that if students are already perfect in their English mastery, they don't need us. They come to us not only to learn, but to be encourage and accompanied in their learning journey. Just my two cents' worth. 

0
I agree with you to an extent. Have you talked or express these concerns to the teachers/tutors that you have selected? This would clear up a lot of issues and pinpoint what you as a learner and the teachers can focus and improve on. You clearly know what you want and desire which is why I agree with you. But there are some that are other learners where they would like to pause and stop at a pronunciation or structure of a sentence. As for me being an unskilled tutor, I let the learner come to me with their concerns and what they would like to learn or improve and then gradually test out their knowledge comparing what they knew before they met me versus after what I've taught them no matter languages, math, history or other subjects. If they just want to have a free flowing conversation with pronunciations and wording exercises afterwards, I also happily obliged. It is best for a pupil to come forward and express what they would love to learn and so on. Good luck on your fluency.
0
The other thing that these rather unskilled tutors disregard is that students often know the correct form and don't need a lecture on verb conjugations. They fail to distinguish between having knowledge of the language and havin acquired it. I will very often self-correct if given time or catch on right away if the tutor responds to what I say using the correct form. It just takes time and focused practice to start using the the forms fluidly and automatically in conversation, and it does not help to be constantly interrupted and scolded.
0
I am a teacher here as well as an active student of languages, and O completely agree with you. I usually write the correction live in a Google document or help the student if I see him struggling, but I agree, I really hate it when tutors jump in and correct immediately, especially if it's delivered like a reprimand. I think sometimes it's about ego - about showing that you need them because they know so much more. It doesn't work. I work with people who focus on exchanging information (and sending me corrections later) not stern types who like giving lectures.

ต้องการความก้าวหน้าที่เร็วขึ้นหรือไม่

เข้าร่วมชุมชนแห่งการเรียนรู้และทดลองใช้แบบฝึกหัดฟรี!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today