ค้นหาจากครู ภาษาอังกฤษ หลากหลายคน...
Japan flagTatsuo Hikasa
I have a question. at Clinic A1. You should go on a diet. B1. I see. A2. I suggest that you lose 15 pounds. B2. I understand. Thank you for the advice. .......................................... I have a question. Text book said "B2. I understand." It can say this: "I understood."

การแก้ไข · 17

2

I have a question.

at the clinic
A1. You should go on a diet.
B1. I see.
A2. I suggest that you lose 15 pounds.
B2. I understand. Thank you for the advice.
..........................................
I have a question.
The text book said "B2. I understand."
Should it have said: "I understood"?
0

I have a question.

at Clinic
A1. You should go on a diet.
B1. I see.
A2. I suggest that you lose 15 pounds.
B2. Understood (Gotcha!). Thank you for the advice.
..........................................
I have a question.
Text book said "B2. I understand."
It can say this: "I understood."

{ THe book's wrong despite other answers nobody talks like that!

The questioner is 100% correct in his doubts }

0

I have a question.

at Clinic
A1. You should go on a diet.
B1. I see.
A2. I suggest that you lose 15 pounds.
B2. I understand. Thank you for the advice.
..........................................
I have a question.
Text book said "B2. I understand."
It can say this: "I understood."

When someone tells you something as a direct statement or suggestion, you reply "I understand" in the present, it is what you have done just now. The understanding occurred moments earlier but it is still in the present.[grammatically] 

If someone asks or enquires about whether you heard. then you can reply with yes I understood.Even if what they told you also only happened moments ago, and was therefore in the past, but now the action of hearing and understanding is finished, so we say "I understood" everything is totally in the past.


There are many situations where things that happened only moments ago are answered in the present tense, even when they are finished and actually happened in the past, but grammatically we say we "understand" in the present. 

In the clinic:

Time 12:47

Doctor: "you should go on a diet" 

You: "I see, I understand" time 12:47.05 [ you can say the extra "I see" for emphasis"

Doctor: "let me check your pulse?"

You: "ok fine" 

doctor takes pulse: 

Doctor: "don't forget to go on a diet!" time 14:48.05.

You" OK I understood" and you can also say "OK I understand" [but only is "I understood" also acceptable for answering this second don't forget statement. But you cannot answer "I understood in reply to the very first question the doctor asked at 12:47

so it is possible in some situations to answer "I understood" 

If the doctor had already mentioned the diet previously a few minutes or seconds earlier in the appointment/examination, then made the statement "you should go on a diet" as a warning or to emphasise or remind you. The you can or could have answered "I understood" or "I understand" 

The textbook question is not helpful for learning the subtleties of English.



0
to John, Thank you.
0
Are A1 and A2 two questions that can be answered with "I understood" "I see" and "I understand" ? Or are A1 and B1 the question and possible answers. and A2 BI the question and possible answers. It is "I understand" but there are circumstances where "I understood could be the answer

ต้องการความก้าวหน้าที่เร็วขึ้นหรือไม่

เข้าร่วมชุมชนแห่งการเรียนรู้และทดลองใช้แบบฝึกหัดฟรี!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today