When we describe something in the past after "to" phrase, do we have to use have + ppt?
This question was from an IELTS exercise book. At first, I thought the answer would be like the following sentence.
Pollution levels in the 1900s are estimated to be higher than they are today.
However, the solution provided from the book would be as follows:
Pollution levels in the 1900s are estimated to have been higher than they are today.
I wonder why we have to put "have been" after "to" instead of just put "be" after "to"? Is it because the pollution levels in the 1900s happened in the past, that's why we use have + ppt after "to"?
ค้นหาจากครู ภาษาอังกฤษ หลากหลายคน...
คำตอบ · 6
3
In this case, the action is completely in the past (i.e., pollution levels in the 1900s are necessarily not the same as they are now, so that status has ended), so you'd use "to have been" which suggests that the condition no longer exists. In this case, it's kind of like the way you'd use 了.
1
Excellent question. I'm afraid so, if you or whoever poses this anal question insists.
Sometimes it needs that "have ppt" to stress the past tense because of some grammatical ban of the prior expressing that fails to embody the tense under certain special situations.
You must do it.
You must have done it. = It's definitely true that you did it.
You seem to have a hard time.
You seem to have had a hard time. = It seems that you had a hard time. (Note that it's not the same as "you seemed to have a hard time". )
Etc. Etc.
1
We use "have been' because the given sentence is in continuous form, that is the pollution levels are still raising and the estimation is still continuing. See from the given sentence
Pollution levels in the 1900s "are" estimated to have been higher than they are today.
here the word "are" denotes the the estimation is taking place in present time hence it is a "present perfect continuous tense" however if it were to be estimated in the past then we would write,
Pollution levels in the 1900s were estimated to be higher than they are today.
1
It gets a little more complicate. The estimating is taking place today. So when we are now talking about it, we talk about what it was i.e. what it has been.
If you say:
Pollution levels in the 1900s were estimated in 1905 to be higher than the foreseeable future.
This is different because you are talking about them in their time frame. So for them it is current.
Just remember that most English speakers wouldn't catch the difference in the two phrases that you wrote. It is subtle.
0
It looks like you had it, meaning now speaking of something happened to you in the past, the speaker (who makes the judge) feels like, or objectively it appears that way (ie "you had it"). The prefix "it seems, it looks like, etc" is more a literal particle than a practical structure in expressing the meaning. Whereas, when you say "you seem/look good, you seem/look like a bad fellow", the subject of the verb "seem" is "you", no longer an "objective view/judge" of the speaker. Thus the statement "you seemed to have a good time" is totally talking about "you", meaning you "seemED" somehow yourself, you DID seem like that in the past, now you DON'T seem so. The point is that the statement is totally about something in tha past. But "you seem to have had it" means you now DO seem somehow. You can understand it this way: "You now DO seem like a man who DID have..." Hope you can figure out the subtle difference. Rather they almost state the same practical meaning.
ยังไม่พบคำตอบของคุณใช่ไหม
เขียนคำถามของคุณเพื่อให้เจ้าของภาษาช่วยคุณ!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
