ค้นหาจากครู ภาษาอังกฤษ หลากหลายคน...
Russia flagDmitry Elle
"I did it" What does it mean? Did I do it completely? Hello everyone, my fellow comrades!) I don't understand some moments in the Past simple. Please, help... I have this sentence: "She read a book yesterday." What does it mean? 1) Complete action. From beginning to end, completely. All the way. 2) Complete action. From chapter 1 to chapter 5 (for example - 5). Thanks a lot!

คำตอบ · 9

2
"She read a book yesterday" means that she read a whole book, from start to finish.
0
She read a book yesterday - only states that she read a book, no mention of duration, how many chapters, paragraph or words. Some books are short and can be read in a short time, some are very long and require a lot of time. I think the point is that she read something yesterday, the process (reading) is being illustrated.
0
I suspected this meaning :) "What did you do yesterday?" - this question may has several meanings...Complete action or unfinished action...Depending on the context. what about "When"? I think, what i've understood it. Jack read some chapters of the book yesterday from 8:00 AM to 10:00 AM Jack was reading a book at 9:00 AM yesterday morning, when his friend, Paul, knocked on the door. Then Jack stopped reading and opened the door. When was Jack doing, when his friend knocked on the door? He was reading a book. What did he do, when his friend knocked on the door? "when" means, what Jack did AFTER his friend knocked on the door. Doesn't it? Jack stopped reading and opened the door. My sister cleaned the room, when mother came home. "when" means, what my sister cleaned the room AFTER mother came home (my sister had cleaned the room, when mother came home. past perfect - result in past. My sister cleaned the room BEFORE mother came home)
0
I am going to agree with Jim that it is ambiguous how much of the book was read (in your sentence). At least, here in the United States, it is very common for people to say things like, "I read a book while I waited for the train." (and the wait might have only been 10 minutes, not enough time to read an entire book). If you want to make the meaning clearer, you'll have to add some more information, such as, "She read several chapters of her book yesterday."
0
Sorry, no, the answer you have been given is wrong. The sentence could mean either 1) or 2), depending on the context. If you wanted to write sentences which clearly distinguished the two meanings, then you would write: 1) She read a whole book yesterday. 2) She spent some time reading a book yesterday. The use of the past simple simply locates the activity "reading a book" some time yesterday, it doesn't imply anything else. Maybe she started reading it yesterday, maybe she finished reading it yesterday, maybe neither: these are all possibilities with reading, which is a long process which could take many days. Other verbs behave differently: for example it usually takes less than a day to make a cake, so "she made a cake yesterday" usually means she made a whole cake, and she made all of it yesterday. If I say "she studied English yesterday" that means she went to school and did her classes. Maybe she did the same thing again today, that is what language students do. If I say "she learned English yesterday" that means she is very clever, maybe too clever.

ยังไม่พบคำตอบของคุณใช่ไหม

เขียนคำถามของคุณเพื่อให้เจ้าของภาษาช่วยคุณ!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today