Simple Past or Present perfect?

Exercise my Solutions ( I am not sure if I am wrong, can someone explain why the other solution is correct?)

1. Yes, of course, I made lunch and wrote a short story for English.
- completed action? simple past

2. Have you helped your Grandma yet?
- signal word yet present perfect

3. Yes, I have. I have been in town...
- I am still in town - present perfect
...and I took out the rubbish.
- Completed action?

4. Have you taken Sam for a walk?
- idk

5. Yes, I have, and I fed him too.[Image]

Question

Simple Past or Present perfect?

Exercise my Solutions ( I am not sure if I am wrong, can someone explain why the other solution is correct?)

1. Yes, of course, I made lunch and wrote a short story for English. 
- completed action? simple past

2. Have you helped your Grandma yet?
- signal word yet present perfect

3. Yes, I have. I have been in town...
- I am still in town - present perfect
...and I took out the rubbish.
- Completed action?

4. Have you taken Sam for a walk?
- idk

5. Yes, I have, and I fed him too.[Image]

Answer

To be honest some of these could be either present perfect or past. All your answers sound ok. The last one could be “have fed”.

Number 3 is odd. It suggests Grandma is in town but it doesn’t really seem relevant.

Answer

3. I was in town and I took out the rubbish.

(In 4 and 5 Lesli's response "Yes, I have," suggests her mother used "Have you taken..", "Have you helped.." etc. but I think more likely a native speaker would use the simple past ie "Did you take Sam for a walk?" "Yes, I did, and I fed him too" for completed actions in the past.)

Answer

2. Did you help grandma yet? or Have you helped grandma yet
3.  I was in town and I took out the rubbish for grandma
4. Did you take Sam for a walk /
5. And I Fed him too

Answer

Hello Alina!

Đừng bỏ lỡ cơ hội học ngoại ngữ ngay tại nhà. Hãy xem danh sách các gia sư ngôn ngữ giàu kinh nghiệm của chúng tôi và đăng ký buổi học đầu tiên ngay hôm nay!