Maria Clara
WHEN SHOULD I USE SHALL? When should I use shall? Does it have the same meaning as will? I have seen some videos about the uses of shall but I'm still confused. Is it something extremely important for my study? 
29 Thg 05 2016 00:10
Bình luận · 5
4

Shall and will are different, and you need to know how to use both.  If you are using textbooks in a course, you'll be taught the difference around pre-intermediate level.  Yes, this means it is important.

We typically use shall for offers and suggestions in question form, and when you use I and we.

Shall I open the window?

Shall we go out for dinner?

It is not possible to use will and keep the same meaning.  "Will I open the window?" means you don't really know!  So, you can start practising your Shall I...? and Shall we...? phrases right now. :)


If you get to upper-intermediate level, you'll see how shall is used for serious obligations. The word shall is often found in legal contracts.

There's no difference between US and UK English here. It's a standard usage.

29 tháng 5 năm 2016
3
Depends. Is your audience American or English?  Americans seldom use shall these days.  If you are writing something formal 'shall' is ok, but if not 'will' sounds more natural to us. 
29 tháng 5 năm 2016
2

Here's a handy guide for these modals... it's not a proper definition, but it gives you the idea behind each modal:

will -> volition

shall -> obligation

Must has the sense of obligation/motivation, but the origin is a little more difficult to describe. Anyway, knowing how shall works can explain the different uses of should (I mean, its uses aside from advice).

29 tháng 5 năm 2016
2
Shall has the same meaning as will, but it is considered to be very formal and archaic, so most people don't use it in regular conversation. I hope that helps! 
29 tháng 5 năm 2016
I used to face "shall" when I was reading a list of Technical requirements from official papers. It was like "The system shall have the next parameters..." And I noticed to myself that in technical English "shall" might be equal to "must". Am I right? Or it's just technical style to write in future tense?
29 tháng 5 năm 2016